What businesses don’t count could cost them profits

Cost-benefit analysis can reveal value that never appears on an invoice

Summarise
阅读简体中文版 (beta)
    • At one Collyer Quay restaurant, business reportedly fell by 70% amid the haze that affected Singapore in October.
    • At one Collyer Quay restaurant, business reportedly fell by 70% amid the haze that affected Singapore in October. PHOTO: TAY CHU YI, BT
    Published Wed, Nov 4, 2026 · 07:00 AM

    WHAT is clean air worth to a restaurant? Diners do not pay for it separately. Yet, when smoke fills the air, the answer becomes painfully clear.

    At one Collyer Quay restaurant, business reportedly fell by 70 per cent amid the haze that affected Singapore in October. Between Oct 5 and 11, poor visibility forced 16 flights to divert from Seletar Airport.

    Businesses that had not produced the smoke nevertheless suffered the consequences.

    The lesson goes beyond haze. Many things that influence commercial success have no obvious price. Companies that overlook them risk making decisions that look sound on paper, but prove costly in practice.

    That is why cost-benefit analysis (CBA) should have a more prominent place in business decisions.

    Value is not the same as price

    Financial appraisal assesses expected cash flows, including revenue, operating expenses and foreseeable risks. Good financial appraisal already considers energy savings and maintenance costs.

    CBA makes a different contribution by encouraging a wider economic perspective. It examines the benefits and costs of decisions, including those without a market price.

    Clean air, shade, tranquillity and people’s time have value, even when nobody sells them separately. Pollution, congestion and noise can also impose costs on others without compensation. These spillover effects are termed “externalities” by economists.

    A 2021 study by Nanyang Technological University’s Professor Euston Quah and Associate Professor Chia Wai Mun, as well as the Singapore University of Social Sciences’ Dr Tan Tsiat Siong, estimated that Singapore’s 2015 haze cost S$1.83 billion.

    That includes about S$360 million in intangible losses valued through a willingness-to-pay approach – what people would spend to prevent the haze – which suggests that the economic burden extended beyond financial transactions to include harm to people’s well-being.

    A full social CBA considers everyone affected, not just a business’ customers. Businesses need not calculate the entire social impact of every investment.

    However, they can apply the same economic reasoning to their own decisions: identify unpriced benefits and costs, estimate their significance and examine where these effects intersect with commercial interests.

    Crucially, recognising economic value is different from earning revenue from it.

    What is a sheltered walkway worth?

    Consider a shopping centre deciding whether to build a covered walkway to a nearby MRT station.

    Construction costs are readily available. But how much do shoppers value arriving dry during a downpour, avoiding the afternoon heat or making the journey easier with young children?

    Management could survey shoppers, study visits at comparable shopping centres or run a small trial to assess how better access changes behaviour.

    Such evidence helps businesses quantify intangible benefits that financial projections alone may overlook, and assess how these could translate into more customer visits, increased spending and ultimately higher profits.

    Suppose the walkway costs S$250,000, has a 10-year lifespan and no residual value. At an illustrative 8 per cent discount rate, the investment needs roughly S$37,000 in additional annual net cash flow to cover its upfront cost.

    Will better access attract more shoppers? Will increased footfall improve tenant sales? More importantly for the landlord, will it lead to higher rents, better occupancy or other income?

    The distinction matters, because greater spending at tenants’ shops does not automatically translate into additional income for the landlord.

    The walkway might create substantial value for shoppers, but generate insufficient revenue for its owner. In that case, management could redesign the project, seek contributions from other beneficiaries or decline the investment.

    CBA does not mean approving whatever customers like. It helps businesses understand what is worth doing, for whom and under what commercial arrangement.

    Better bids and better products

    The same reasoning applies to companies competing for projects.

    Imagine a contractor bidding to upgrade a shopping street. A cheaper construction method closes access to shops for weeks. An alternative option costs more, but allows businesses to remain accessible.

    Estimating the value of avoided disruption enables the contractor to demonstrate why the higher-priced proposal may offer better overall value.

    Singapore’s government-procurement framework explicitly looks beyond the lowest price to consider quality, reliability, risks and long-term costs.

    As at March 2025, environmental sustainability considerations are applied to 60 per cent of government procurement by contract value, with the aim of extending them to all procurement by 2028.

    Not every tender requires formal CBA. Contractors must still demonstrate how the benefits relate to the buyer’s evaluation criteria. Nevertheless, the ability to substantiate value can create an advantage over competing solely on price.

    Understanding non-market benefits can also help businesses develop products and services.

    A clinic can estimate what patients value about shorter waiting times; a logistics company can examine the benefits customers derive from reliable delivery; a hotel can assess the value of quieter rooms.

    Businesses can use these insights to improve their offerings, attract customers and potentially command higher prices.

    The green economy offers a useful reminder of the limits. In the Singlife-SGFIN Sustainable Future Index 2026, 65 per cent of surveyed respondents said they were willing to buy from more sustainable companies, but only 38 per cent were willing to pay higher prices.

    Environmental benefits may be valued without translating into stronger sales or higher profits. Companies must establish what customers are actually willing to pay, rather than rely solely on what they say they value.

    Putting CBA to work

    For businesses, CBA should be more than an academic exercise or a requirement attached to major public projects.

    Before approving a significant investment, executives should ask three questions:

    • First, what meaningful costs and benefits might our financial projections have overlooked, including non-market effects and externalities?
    • Second, what evidence supports their economic value, and who stands to benefit or bear the costs?
    • Third, can recognising these effects help us improve revenue, reduce costs, manage risks or strengthen our competitive position?

    A useful assessment compares realistic alternatives, including doing nothing. It considers costs and benefits over the project’s lifetime, tests uncertain assumptions and avoids counting the same gains twice.

    Not every decision requires an elaborate study. The analysis should be proportionate to the investment and the significance of its potential consequences.

    CBA may reveal that an investment should be redesigned or rejected. Equally, it may identify a service customers would pay more for, a risk worth preventing or a stronger approach to winning contracts.

    The objective is not to replace financial appraisal, nor to pursue benefits that a company cannot afford to deliver. It is to improve commercial decisions by understanding economic value, before determining whether that value can translate into financial returns.

    Businesses know how to put a price on what they sell.

    Their next competitive advantage may lie in recognising the value of what nobody sells separately.

    Professor Euston Quah, president of the Economic Society of Singapore (ESS), is the Albert Winsemius chair professor of economics and director of the Economic Growth Centre at Nanyang Technological University. Dr Eugene Or, honorary assistant secretary of ESS, is a lecturer at the Singapore University of Social Sciences.