Recently, I had the pleasure of watching an international magician perform. He began by producing a dove from a prop resembling a book. The moment the dove appeared, the audience broke into applause.
Yet, strangely, my attention remained fixed on the dove. Magic cannot create life out of thin air. I could not help wondering: where had the dove been before the audience saw it?
Perhaps it had been hidden up a sleeve, or tucked into a secret compartment in the prop, waiting for the moment it would be “conjured up”.
After the performance, I watched the magician casually place the dove in a small bag beside him, then close the clasp at the opening to stop it flying away. A question came to mind: if the dove could speak, how would it describe the performance?
For the audience, it was a few seconds of wonder. For the dove, however, it might have meant long waits, transport in cramped conditions and being used as a prop time and again.
Some might argue that it wasn’t injured. But animal welfare has never been just about whether an animal has physical wounds. We shouldn’t set the bar at “as long as it is alive”.
What is truly amazing about magic should not merely be a dove appearing out of thin air, but rather the performer's creativity, skill and imagination.
With stage technology now capable of creating countless stunning visual effects, why must we still make animals part of so-called “entertainment”?
I do not assume that this magician broke any relevant laws. But the law should be seen as a baseline, not the pinnacle of a civilised society. Is something acceptable simply because it’s legal?
We can perhaps work towards more transparent oversight and stricter animal welfare standards, and even gradually reduce the number of acts that use animals as props. We should appreciate animals as they are and respect their natural behaviour.
I would like to close with a comment I once saw beneath a video: “The way a country treats animals determines how civilised it is.” Only when I saw that dove being put back into the bag did I suddenly understand what those words meant.
A society’s progress is never measured solely by its skyscrapers, technology, and economic numbers. It is found in our willingness to pause — just for a second — to consider the voiceless among us.