After the ruling People's Action Party (PAP) announced its latest 14-member central executive committee (CEC) line-up on 25 October, some political observers said the election results showed that party cadres distinguished between the government and party leadership teams.
According to these observers, this showed that, amid global and regional geopolitical uncertainty, they preferred to keep the existing leadership at the helm.
There is merit in this view, but interpreting the results solely through cadres’ voting preferences does not give the full picture.
First, the PAP’s practice of recommending candidates in this election should not be overlooked. It is understood that the list of 19 candidates was drawn up by branch secretaries, branch chairs and the outgoing CEC, among others. The outgoing CEC then recommended seven of them to cadres — the group commonly known as the “core seven”.
According to party insiders, the seven were Prime Minister Lawrence Wong, Senior Minister Lee Hsien Loong, Desmond Lee, Chan Chun Sing, Masagos Zulkifli, Senior Minister K. Shanmugam and Grace Fu.
This was largely unchanged from the 2024 election, with the main difference being Desmond Lee, who had been appointed party chairman, replacing former chairman Heng Swee Keat, who was stepping down. Masagos, formerly the minister-in-charge of Muslim affairs and widely seen as someone who might make way, remained on the list.
This suggested that the leadership was in no hurry to complete that transition by handing over to Zaqy Mohamad, who had just become Acting Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs.
However, the leadership’s recommendations did not make cadres’ choices irrelevant. After the first round of voting, Dr Tan See Leng and Zaqy, who ranked 13th and 14th respectively, were co-opted into the CEC.
Jeffrey Siow and Jasmin Lau, who were appointed political office-holders after the 2025 general election, made the candidate list but did not enter the CEC at this stage. This showed that new political office-holders still need to build party experience and a support base among cadres.
The CEC’s composition also maintained the PAP’s emphasis on diverse representation. The retention of SM Shanmugam, Masagos, Indranee Rajah, Fu, Zaqy and co-opted member Sim Ann, among others, preserved minority and female representation in the leadership.
Ng Chee Meng’s co-option continued to reflect the symbiotic relationship between the PAP and the labour movement.
The PAP also made room for those who had not been elected to Parliament, co-opting grassroots adviser Chan Hui Yuh, who contested Aljunied Group Representation Constituency unsuccessfully in the 2025 general election.
This continued the tradition of recognising candidates who contest difficult constituencies, with the aim of strengthening grassroots morale and fighting spirit.
The PAP also continued to use its internal mechanisms to test new political office-holders. Besides co-opting Siow when the CEC elected its office-holders on 5 November, the party adjusted the leadership of several internal groups, handing the reins to new political office-holders.
For example, three who had not been nominated for the CEC election took on new responsibilities: Minister for Culture, Community and Youth David Neo took charge of the PAP Seniors Group, Senior Minister of State for Home Affairs and Social and Family Development Goh Pei Ming became chairman of the Climate Action Group, and Minister of State for Manpower and Culture, Community and Youth Dinesh Vasu Dash became assistant organising secretary.
These roles, leading groups with specific remits and helping to coordinate party work, give new political office-holders front-line party experience while avoiding putting too many new faces to an electoral test too soon.
Lau, who had been on the candidate list, was neither co-opted nor appointed to another important party post. Does this mean her prospects within the party are limited?
In fact, even if new political office-holders are not directly elected in the party’s formal elections or co-opted afterwards, they can still be brought in later when senior leaders step down from the CEC. This ensures an orderly leadership transition, to some extent.
Looking back, Heng, Chan Chun Sing and Tan Chuan-Jin, who became political office-holders after the 2011 general election, were appointed to the CEC after six senior party members, including founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew and Emeritus Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong, stepped down from it.
A year later, they entered the CEC either through their vote rankings or by co-option. This July, Zaqy was similarly co-opted into the CEC after taking over the Muslim affairs portfolio from Faishal Ibrahim.
The PAP’s latest CEC line-up thus reflects an approach that uses targeted endorsements to maintain continuity in its core team, elections to test candidates’ support within the party, specific party responsibilities to develop newcomers and co-option to retain room for adjustments.
In short, the PAP is making small changes to preserve overall stability as it seeks to navigate a highly unpredictable external environment.
The effectiveness of this gradual adjustment in maintaining stability will depend not only on whether the existing team can continue to perform, but also on whether newcomers are able to gain substantive experience and take on greater leadership responsibilities at the right time.
(The writer is a special correspondent for Lianhe Zaobao.)