US President Donald J. Trump campaigned on “Make America Great Again” and made “America First” the central principle of his administration, promising to revive manufacturing, create jobs and improve people’s lives. He has indeed introduced related measures, including tax cuts, moves to lower mortgage rates and prescription drug prices, and tighter immigration controls. But the results have been lacklustre, falling far short of voters’ expectations.
Figures released by the US Bureau of Economic Analysis show that real gross domestic product (GDP) grew at an annualised rate of 3.4% in the third quarter of this year, up from 2.2% in the second quarter. This suggests that the US economy remained fairly resilient. Yet GDP growth does not mean everyone benefits. Voters have gradually come to realise that economic growth has not translated into better lives for ordinary families. Instead, living costs have soared, while close ties between the government and the ultra-rich, technology giants and major conglomerates have also deepened public concerns that wealth and political resources are becoming even more concentrated at the top.
The Trump administration has used tariffs to encourage manufacturers to bring production back to the US, hoping to create more jobs. But tariff costs inevitably get passed on to businesses and consumers, pushing up prices. Bringing manufacturing back takes time, and restructuring industries cannot happen overnight. Meanwhile, international military conflicts, such as the US-Iran war, fluctuating energy prices and uncertainty over trade policy have put additional pressure on business investment and ordinary households.
An Associated Press survey of more than 100,000 voters during the midterm elections found that nearly 90% of respondents considered cost of living as an "crucial” or "major” factor in their vote. About two-thirds believed Trump’s policies had made the economy worse, and a similar proportion thought his policies had fuelled inflation. Some 70% said the economy favoured the wealthy. In a speech to the Federalist Society on the 14th of this month, Secretary of State Marco Rubio also acknowledged that people were struggling. The issue, he said, was not how the economy was performing overall, but whether people had enough money to meet their living expenses. This shows just how crucial bread-and-butter issues are.
Another development in the US economy worth noting is the so-called “K-shaped economy”, in which the fortunes of different groups diverge during economic recovery or growth. Wealthy households that own assets such as shares and property can often benefit from rising asset values. Ordinary workers who rely mainly on wages, however, may face simultaneous increases in food, housing, healthcare and energy costs.
According to a report released this year by the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO), the average ratio of chief executive pay to ordinary employee pay at S&P 500 companies in 2025 was still 312 to one, even after excluding Tesla boss Elon Musk’s exceptionally large pay package. This was up from 285 to one in 2024. While these figures do not represent all US companies, they highlight the enormous income gap between senior executives and ordinary employees at large corporations.
Singapore’s experience: balancing efficiency and fairness
This also elucidates how economic growth and the distribution of its gains are equally important. Even if a country boasts world-leading tech firms, robust capital markets and scores of billionaires, the social foundations of its economic development warrant scrutiny if workers cannot earn incomes commensurate with their contributions and wealth is excessively concentrated.
Singapore differs greatly from the US in land area, population, political system and economic structure. Even so, its approach to balancing economic competitiveness and social equity offers lessons worth considering.
The Singapore government has long utilised fiscal transfers, household assistance, public services and support for businesses to ease living costs across income groups. Notably, it does not rely solely on subsidies, but seeks to link workers’ incomes, business productivity and social equity.
Singapore’s GDP grew by 5.4% year on year in the third quarter of this year. In October, the National Wages Council released its wage guidelines for 2026/2027, recommending pay increases of 6% to 8%, or at least S$120, for lower-wage employees earning up to S$2,800 a month. It must be stressed that these guidelines are not legally binding. Rather, they emerge from tripartite consultations among the government, employers and unions, guiding businesses to share the gains from economic and productivity growth with employees according to their performance and ability to pay.
In addition, measures such as the Progressive Wage Model, the Progressive Wage Credit Scheme and the Workfare Income Supplement Scheme help lower-wage workers raise their incomes while providing transitional support to businesses. The emphasis is on improving workers’ pay and conditions while taking account of businesses’ operating capacity and long-term competitiveness.
Singapore’s experience shows that improving people’s lives cannot depend solely on higher government welfare spending, nor can income distribution be left entirely to the market. Governments must design appropriate systems that enable businesses to keep growing, allow employees to share in productivity gains and provide vulnerable groups with the protection they need.
On government capability, Singapore ranked first among 133 countries and territories in this year’s Chandler Good Government Index, while the US ranked 26th. The index primarily measures government capabilities, institutional development and governance performance, rather than people’s happiness or living standards directly. Nonetheless, it remains a useful reference for assessing public administration across countries. Singapore’s sustained lead reflects its strengths in policy implementation, fiscal management and public policy planning.
Ultimately, a country’s strength or a government’s performance cannot be judged solely by how much GDP or share prices have risen, how many billionaires it has, or how much influence it wields internationally. What matters more is whether ordinary wage earners receive reasonable incomes, whether young families can afford housing and the cost of raising children, whether the elderly can enjoy a secure retirement, and whether vulnerable groups receive the social protection they deserve. All of this boils down to bread-and-butter issues. While economic growth is the bedrock of national development, the true measure of governance lies in ensuring that the people share in the fruits of this progress.
Political slogans can rally votes, economic figures can showcase achievements, and international rankings can demonstrate competitiveness. But what ultimately determines whether people trust a government is the reality of their daily lives. Whether in the US, Singapore or elsewhere, the principle remains the same: people’s well-being must come first in governance. As some have put it, a country’s development is measured by its overall strength; but the humanity of its governance is measured by how its people live. There is much truth in that.
The author is a former journalist and former Member of Parliament.