China is solving the wrong consumption problem
Beijing wants to make shopping more satisfying, but consumers already have a choice of high-quality goods
BEIJING’S first-ever five-year consumption road map, unveiled last week, has failed to deliver the bold measures needed to make personal spending the higher strategic priority that policymakers promised.
If anything, many of its details point in the opposite direction.
For one, the stated official target of 60 trillion yuan (US$8.9 trillion) in retail sales by 2030 implies that expansion will slow to just 3.7 per cent annually from 2026 onward – far lower than the 5.3 per cent recorded during the previous plan, which included the height of the pandemic.
At such a tepid rate, it’s difficult to see how consumption’s percentage of gross domestic product could rise significantly from the current 40 per cent, compared with about 70 per cent for the US and 50 per cent for Japan.
Targeting the wrong areas
It’s squandering a chance to strengthen demand. If household consumption accounted for the same share of the economy as in rival countries, China would probably run a trade deficit, easing a major source of geopolitical friction and boosting the prospects of dozens of consumer companies. It would also lend further support to global growth.
The strategies aimed at getting buyers excited again seem to focus on the wrong areas.
Instead of laying out ambitious steps to improve incomes and ability to spend – such as resolving the housing crisis, investing in social services, dismantling entrenched regional disparities or improving job prospects for fresh graduates – the approach centres on making shopping marginally more satisfying. For example, there is an emphasis on improving food safety and the quality of tourist accommodation.
But that misses the mark. Home-grown brands are already engaged in brutal competition, offering ever-lower prices and better products to entice shoppers.
From Xiaomi’s smartphones to Luckin Coffee’s drinks, there is little evidence that a shortage of attractive products is what’s holding back spending. The problem is households’ reluctance to open their wallets.
To be sure, Beijing’s nationwide trade-in programme, which has subsidised purchases of cars, home appliances and electronics since 2024, has provided some support.
Still, the scheme has largely served to prop up high-tech industrial champions rather than put more money in pockets.
Even so, funding was reduced this year just as additional stimulus was most needed. Last month, domestic sales of passenger cars dropped by nearly a quarter, reflecting a saturated market and reduced government subsidies.
Exports, by contrast, jumped more than 80 per cent.
Corporate earnings deteriorated for a third consecutive year in 2025. Roughly one in four listed companies reported losses. Consumer-oriented firms are trading at low valuation multiples, reflecting expectations for years of anaemic growth.
Until households have more money to spend and less reason to save, incremental improvements won’t do much. Even though household consumption’s share of GDP is low by global standards, because of historically high home prices and limited welfare provision, it has increased significantly – growing by 150 per cent in the decade to 2019 before being interrupted by the pandemic and property rout.
Little incentive for more support
Much of the weakness reflects real estate’s outsized impact on personal wealth. That’s why some influential economists as well as the Communist Party’s own top journal have called for a more robust policy response that could include cash injections into the ailing sector.
Policymakers have alternated between relying on overseas sales and domestic demand to support growth over decades.
With exports of chips, computer parts and power equipment driving China’s trade boom in the first half of the year, officials have little incentive to deploy the kind of large-scale reforms needed to meaningfully lift household consumption.
Macquarie economists Larry Hu and Zhang Yuxiao believe Beijing will continue to do “just enough” – providing only the support required to meet its growth target while avoiding the sweeping measures required to address deeper structural problems. That makes the consumption plan more of a statement of priorities rather than a proper blueprint. The strategy may work while exports outperform.
But it also means China will remain dependent on foreign demand at a time when trading partners are increasingly pushing back and causing potential diplomatic disputes.
Not doing more to stimulate spending is a missed opportunity. BLOOMBERG
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds
Nvidia’s outlook cut to stable by Moody’s on governance concerns