For her tenth birthday, my daughter invited friends over to play. Some could not come because they had tuition, while others played for a while before rushing off to their lessons. The few who stayed played from afternoon until evening, then pleaded for a little more time.
A recent survey by the Institute of Policy Studies in Singapore may shed light on this. The proportion of parents who had felt stressed about their children's education over the past year rose from about 70% a decade ago to nearly 90%. Nearly 90% of parents felt their children spent too much time on tuition and enrichment classes.
When a family drops a tuition class, the child gains some free time. But as other families continue to invest in such lessons, parents inevitably worry that their child will fall behind in future. It becomes even harder for children to find an afternoon when everyone is free to play together.
Schools have reduced some examinations and tests over the years, and there is good reason for doing so. The survey also showed that parents' anxiety about examinations and homework had eased.
But the pressure has not disappeared along with the tests. Instead, the question has changed: is my child fulfilling their potential?
An examination paper can be handed in once it is finished. With “potential”, there is no finishing point.
No sooner does a child develop an interest in an activity than parents worry that stopping will mean falling behind. They set out to give their children more choices, only to find that every choice requires advance preparation. The time that has been freed up by lighter school workloads may then be filled back up by families once more.
As extracurricular classes proliferate, the financial and time costs vary from family to family. For some, even arranging regular transport to and from a class is difficult. All-round development should give children more opportunities beyond academic achievement. It must not become another contest over who starts preparing earlier and invests more.
This is not about blaming parents who send their children for tuition. The question worth asking is whether, when signing them up for classes, we are responding to their actual needs now or to our fear that they will fall behind in the future.
Families should also consider whether their children's schedules still leave room for time that is not geared towards grades, certificates or selection exercises. Play is not a course whose value has yet to be proven. As children chase one another, argue, make up and renegotiate how to play, they are already learning to get along with others.
If a primary school child spending an afternoon playing with friends strikes adults as a rare treat, then perhaps our discussions about easing children's workloads have left something out: time of their own.