A month ago in France, the clock tower of Limoges’s town hall, built in 1883 and a survivor of both world wars, toppled amid flames and crashed through the building’s roof. Shattered shop windows littered the Champs-Élysées in Paris; shops in Marseille were looted; and Lyon’s tourism office was set ablaze. Destruction during subsequent demonstrations continued unabated.
At first glance, this seems a paradox: in a country many regard as a model of democracy, why do people express their demands by burning their own cities?
To answer that question, we must first separate two things that have become conflated. One is the peaceful marches involving hundreds of thousands of people. The other is the small group of masked, black-clad people on the fringes of the crowds who deliberately target shops and public buildings.
The French government blames the latter on the “far left” and criminals. Far-left leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon, in turn, accuses the police of creating chaos, blocking routes and using tear gas excessively. The truth probably lies somewhere between: most people taking to the streets have genuine, legitimate grievances, while the violence comes from a small minority hijacking that anger.
Where does the “genuine anger” come from?
A 36-year-old protester put it simply to CNN, “There’s an accumulation of wealth and power that’s completely out of control.” Another protester, aged 38, spoke of “less democracy” and a “concentration of power”. These are not abstract political slogans. They reflect the realities of daily life. Cumulative inflation in France is expected to reach around 24% by the end of this year, with fuel prices, rents and food prices rising in turn, while nearly 900,000 public servants live below the poverty line.
Meanwhile, schools lack teachers, classrooms are overcrowded, hospitals are understaffed and the quality of public services is visibly declining. When someone pays their taxes on time and follows the rules, only to find their child sitting in a classroom with a leaking roof and no full-time teacher, while elites on television discuss budget cuts and benefit freezes, the voice they express through the ballot box begins to sound like a hollow echo.
France’s problem is also that its political system amplifies this “hollow echo”. The Fifth Republic was designed from the outset to avoid parliamentary chaos by giving the president extensive powers. But when the president’s camp loses its parliamentary majority and the president refuses to make concessions to the left, a peculiar impasse emerges: the streets become the only place where people can still “speak”, because the parliamentary route is blocked. This is not a uniquely French affliction, but France’s tradition of street protest makes it particularly conspicuous.
Yet conflating “justified anger” with “burning down a town hall” is precisely what poses the gravest danger to democracy.
A fundamental tenet of a democratic system is this: you may protest, strike, block roads and denounce the president, but you cannot hold a city hostage. When masked people smash the windows of the corner bakery and loot it, they are taking the owner’s life savings. When young people set bins and cars alight, the smoke chokes neighbours who are also worrying about their bills at the end of the month. Violence never lands precisely on “those responsible”. It lands on whoever is nearest. Those marching peacefully understand this better than anyone, which is why they say the violence is the work of “troublemakers”, not theirs.
From the standpoint of freedom and human rights, this needs to be stated more plainly. The right to peaceful protest is the lifeblood of democracy, but using violence to rob others of their personal safety and property tramples on those same rights. A protester holding a placard demanding more democracy and someone else burning down a town hall cannot both be defended under the same banner. The former is exercising their freedom; the latter is denying others theirs. French President Emmanuel Macron is not wrong to say there must be “zero tolerance for violence”. The problem is that if a system can hear anger only after violence erupts, it is already failing those who have remained peaceful.
The fire in France points not to a conclusion as simple as “democracy has failed”, but to a more difficult question: when a democracy persistently fails to respond through institutional channels to the most basic needs for a dignified livelihood and public services, radicalisation on the streets becomes a predictable symptom of dysfunction. The system need not answer for every act of destruction by a masked rioter, but it must answer the question: “Why do so many people feel they have no other option?”
After the clock tower collapsed, the mayor of Limoges said, “It is a monument that is burning, not the Republic.” Those are moving words, but they hold true only if the Republic genuinely hears those peaceful voices. If they could be heard, the fire should never have been started. Once it has broken out, condemning the flames alone is not enough. We must also look back and ask why the place where people were supposed to have a voice fell silent.
(The writer is a science writer from China.)