Rethinking authority: A systems thinking perspective on Singaporean workplaces
By Rachika RastogiThe challenge is not to surrender authority but to make authority more receptive to information.
Authority establishes who holds final decision-making power; however, it does not necessarily indicate who holds the knowledge required for well-informed decisions.
In Singaporean workplaces, leaders generally possess authority by virtue of their position, seniority, and organisational responsibilities. However, authority alone does not guarantee effective decision-making. In knowledge-intensive organisations, sound decisions depend not only on the right to decide but also on access to relevant information, expertise, and diverse viewpoints.
This raises a wider question: Can hierarchical orders provide direction without implying that higher positions inherently contribute more to organisational success? The central issue is not whether organisations should eliminate hierarchy or promote continual dissent. Rather, it concerns whether authority can remain clear and accountable whilst recognising that valuable knowledge exists at all organisational levels.
For example, an employee who interacts directly with customers may identify recurring problems that senior management has not observed. Similarly, a technical specialist may detect risks that are not apparent to generalist leaders, and a frontline manager may understand how a policy functions in practice rather than in theory. This distinction signals the separation between decision rights and organisational knowledge. Hierarchy can delineate levels of authority without necessarily differentiating the value of individual contributions inside the organisation.
Chester Barnard’s Acceptance Theory of Authority provides a valuable perspective. Rather than viewing authority solely as a function of position, Barnard emphasised the recipient's role: Authority becomes meaningful only when it is accepted as a basis for action. This framework supplies a foundation for re-examining how authority operates beyond formal hierarchies.
When voice reaches authority
If knowledge is distributed throughout an organisation, employee voice becomes one way that knowledge can reach decision-makers. Yet having a feedback mechanism does not necessarily mean employees will use it, nor does it guarantee their contributions will influence organisational thinking. Singaporean work setting demonstrates the significance of this distinction.
According to Ministry of Manpower data from 2023, amongst employees who experienced workplace discrimination but did not seek assistance, 24.4% cited fear of marginalisation or strained workplace relationships, whilst 18.2% expressed concerns about their careers or future job opportunities. These statistics indicate that official channels do not inherently foster confidence in their use.
Gallup’s 2026 State of the Global Workplace report found that only 18% of employees in East Asia were engaged at work, whilst 66% were not engaged and 16% were actively disengaged.
Although these engagement figures do not establish a causal link between hierarchy and disengagement, they underscore the importance of scrutinising daily manager-employee interactions. Consequently, the wider inquiry goes beyond the following consideration. "Do employees possess a meaningful voice within the organisation?" Instead, the central question becomes: "What are the organisational implications when an individual with less formal authority possesses knowledge that is not available to those with greater authority?"
Dissent does not necessarily signify opposition to leadership; rather, it may reflect information that has not yet reached those in leadership positions.
Making authority receptive
The challenge for managers is not to surrender authority but to make authority more receptive to information. This approach does not necessitate converting every decision into a consultative process. Instead, it begins by distinguishing the right to decide from the opportunity to provide information before decisions are made.
Managers may assist this process by posing the following questions: What information or perspectives might be missing? What possible risks are apparent? What alternative approaches would you recommend? Who possesses the most direct experience with this issue? These questions do not transfer decision-making authority; instead, they improve the quality of the decision-making process.
Managers may also encourage dissenting viewpoints before expressing their own views and, when appropriate, permit less-senior employees to contribute before those with greater authority. This approach prevents the initial senior opinion from being perceived as the default organisational stance.
However, inviting input is not enough. How you respond to employee contributions matters just as much. If employees raise concerns through feedback channels but receive no explanation afterward, participation can become a procedural exercise rather than meaningful engagement.
Managers can strengthen this process by explaining the rationale behind decisions, acknowledging when employee input influenced outcomes, and clarifying when and why they did not adopt alternative suggestions.
Such practices do not undermine hierarchical orders. Instead, they enhance hierarchy's utility.
Authority through systems thinking
An organisation is a system made up of interrelated roles, the flow of information, decisions, actions, and consequences. A decision at one level can have an effect on other levels, and the ones affected might possess information which the original decision-maker does not have.
This context illustrates the value of systems thinking. Instead of centring solely on who holds authority, systems thinking examines how information circulates within the organisation, where feedback is generated or lost, and how decisions impact other components of the system.
Organisations can evaluate these conditions by looking beyond employee participation rates. For instance, surveys can determine whether employees know how and where to raise concerns. Feedback audits can track how often dissenting views or identified risks reach decision-makers and whether these inputs guide outcomes.
Additionally, tracking the number and outcomes of raised concerns, and conducting follow-up interviews or focus groups, can reveal how leadership engages and whether employee or frontline knowledge informs subsequent decisions.
Hierarchy can provide structure. Authority can provide accountability. Expertise is able to provide knowledge. Participation can provide information. Dissent can provide feedback.
Rethinking authority
The challenge for Singaporean organisations is not to choose between hierarchy and dissent, but to understand how these elements can function in synergy within the organisational system.
The effectiveness of the organisational system depends, in part, on how interconnected these elements remain. Authority loses effectiveness when people automatically equate higher positions with superior knowledge. Conversely, distributed knowledge diminishes in value if employees cannot contribute it to organisational decision-making processes.
For Singaporean organisations operating in increasingly complex, knowledge-intensive environments, the main challenge is to balance authority with humility.
Decision-making authority may be hierarchical, but organisational value exists at every level.