Experts flag execution risks in $1.82b Town Hall Link bid
Consultants said the substantial office and infrastructure requirements narrowed the bidding field.
The two bids received for the Town Hall Link white site reflected developers’ caution towards large integrated projects and uncertainty over future suburban office demand, property consultants said.
A consortium comprising CapitaLand Development, Sing Holdings, Far East Organization and Sino Group submitted the highest bid of about $1.82b, equivalent to $910 psf per plot ratio.
The offer was nearly 39% above the second bid of approximately $1.31b, suggesting that the bidders held substantially different views about the value that could be extracted from the site.
The 3.72-hectare Jurong Lake District plot has a maximum gross floor area of about 2 million sq ft. It could yield approximately 1,200 homes, at least 40,000 sq m of office space and between 20,000 and 44,000 sq m of retail space.
Knight Frank Singapore Head of Research Leonard Tay said the two bids were within expectations because the project still represented a substantial undertaking despite being smaller than the Jurong Lake District master-developer site rejected in 2024.
He said developers would have weighed the site’s strategic position and transport connectivity against its infrastructure requirements and the untested popularity of suburban offices.
Corporate occupiers continued to prefer the Central Business District because of prestige, amenities and more equitable commuting times for employees, Tay said.
Knight Frank estimated that office users would be unlikely to pay more than $7.50 psf per month for space outside the Central Region, even in a new building with high-quality facilities.
The firm also cautioned that the $910 psf ppr bid, whilst 42% higher than the offer for the rejected master-developer site, could still fall below the government’s reserve price.
PropNex Head of Research and Content Wong Siew Ying described the top offer as measured rather than aggressive.
She said the significant capital commitment and need for expertise across residential, office and retail development naturally limited the tender to well-capitalised developers and consortiums.
The smaller plot and the government’s decision to take on more infrastructure and land-preparation work probably reduced bidders’ costs and risks compared with the earlier master site, she added.
PropNex expects the residential component to attract healthy demand from HDB upgraders in western Singapore and buyers drawn to the site’s future access to four MRT lines.
The agency estimated that the development could achieve an average selling price above $2,800 psf, supported by its connectivity, integrated format and the wider transformation of Jurong Lake District.
Huttons Asia CEO Mark Yip said the offer was likely the highest land-price quantum recorded for a white site outside the Central Area.
He said direct links to Jurong East MRT interchange and the future Jurong Lake District station, together with the retail podium and planned employment growth, would support its appeal to residents and investors.
Huttons also expects office-development risks to ease as Singapore’s supply of new office space peaks in 2028 and tapers over the following three years.
URA has not awarded the site. The authority said it would announce its decision after evaluating the bids.